XNK3563
Re: XNK3563
Are you really sure, Herschi? Is his biography, Hans Billian refers to Christine Szenetra as "Christa" and to XNK3563 as "Marianne" - a girl he originally wanted to have as Josefine Mutzenbacher in "Die Beichte der J. M.". But Marianne got cold feet after a while - she was afraid it would ruin her husband's career as a teacher - and bowed out. But she did return later, and played the maid in "Haus der geheimen L?ste".
Szenetra, however, appeared in several films during this period, seemingly without inhibition.
Szenetra, however, appeared in several films during this period, seemingly without inhibition.
Re: XNK3563
Hello mulholand!
Yes, I am sure.
I have checked 7 films.
Thanks for the new Informations!
______
Herschi
Yes, I am sure.
I have checked 7 films.
Thanks for the new Informations!
______
Herschi
Re: XNK3563
Hello Herschi!
You certainly seem very certain...
To your advantage, there's a Billian comment on "Marianne" having lost a few pounds when reporting for work for "Haus" (a weight-loss he found slightly to her disadvantage). Then, there's the hair-colour... but that's probably doable, too.
My "devil's advocate" bit remains: it's a bit strange that Billian introduces the same girl with two different names in his book. Furthermore, he describes one of them ("Christa") as being very "gung ho" and the other one ("Marianne") as equally careful (she turned down a fee of 10000 DM for the lead in "Beichte"). But perhaps "Christa" had a short period of a "quiet" life and then returned (after which, for reasons only known to himself, Billian decided to call her "Marianne"). This is not at all indicated in the book, though.
You may well be right, Herschi, there is a likeness. But also some differences.
You certainly seem very certain...
To your advantage, there's a Billian comment on "Marianne" having lost a few pounds when reporting for work for "Haus" (a weight-loss he found slightly to her disadvantage). Then, there's the hair-colour... but that's probably doable, too.
My "devil's advocate" bit remains: it's a bit strange that Billian introduces the same girl with two different names in his book. Furthermore, he describes one of them ("Christa") as being very "gung ho" and the other one ("Marianne") as equally careful (she turned down a fee of 10000 DM for the lead in "Beichte"). But perhaps "Christa" had a short period of a "quiet" life and then returned (after which, for reasons only known to himself, Billian decided to call her "Marianne"). This is not at all indicated in the book, though.
You may well be right, Herschi, there is a likeness. But also some differences.
Re: XNK3563
Welcome back to the forum Herschi your expertise on German films is always welcome. I do share Mulholand's doubt about this. Christine Szenetra was one of my favourite actresses of the 70's amd I have to confess when I saw 'Haus' it never occurred to me that the maid was Christine. I am awaiting the arrival of a dvd of the film 'Harry' which Christine appears it, I shall look at it carefully and compare. Billian was certainly right about her being gung-ho.
Incidentally it was claimed in another thread that Billian has died, can you our someone else confirm please?
Incidentally it was claimed in another thread that Billian has died, can you our someone else confirm please?
-
beutelwolf
- Posts: 1210
- Joined: Fri Jul 14, 2017 2:40 am
Re: XNK3563
mulholand wrote:
> To your advantage, there's a Billian comment on "Marianne"
> having lost a few pounds when reporting for work for "Haus" (a
> weight-loss he found slightly to her disadvantage). Then,
> there's the hair-colour... but that's probably doable, too.
Hair colour does not mean a thing - in the old days, they coloured pubic hair to make a match.
But I have my doubts too. There is a facial similarity, but I thought "Marianne" was taller than Christine Szenetra. On balance, I would think it is not her.
> To your advantage, there's a Billian comment on "Marianne"
> having lost a few pounds when reporting for work for "Haus" (a
> weight-loss he found slightly to her disadvantage). Then,
> there's the hair-colour... but that's probably doable, too.
Hair colour does not mean a thing - in the old days, they coloured pubic hair to make a match.
But I have my doubts too. There is a facial similarity, but I thought "Marianne" was taller than Christine Szenetra. On balance, I would think it is not her.